Narrow Stairs, the 6th studio album by Death Cab for Cutie, expected to be released on May 13, 2008 in the US, seems to lack the subtle but intriguing impact of prior albums. Upon the first few listens, only a few tracks stand out. The album starts out well, with “Bixby Canyon Bridge”, followed by the single “I Will Posses Your Heart”. The album version reaching a total of eight and a half minutes, which remains instrumental for just over halfway.
After the first few tracks, you begin to find something different, without quite being able to put your finger on it. Yes, its good, but something isn’t quite right. When Ben Gibbards vocals kick in, they remain somewhat lackluster (something I’ve never experienced in any of his other work). While his voice still remains as one of the most brilliant today, it somehow doesn’t reach the same level as once achieved in The Photo Album, or Give Up (Postal Service). The usual guitar and piano riddled songs are still there, but don’t enhance Gibbards vocals to the extent seen before.
On the other hand, the lyrics are still more than incredible. While it can be said that Gibbards vocals have less impact than usual, they are still more than enough to carry this album through and far way from mediocrity. Less frequent moments of transcendence keep you wanting more. Just as this moment comes along, and fades away, you wonder why they didn’t just keep going. This is perfectly exemplified in “You Can Do Better Than Me”. What seems to be a very average song, gains its appeal right at the end, before leaping into the next track.
Just as the album is drawing to a close, Gibbard sings “The Ice Is Getting Thinner”, which could easily have been heard on Transatlanticsm. It is in this song that everything comes together in a short, softly bound conclusion. The vocal tones and melodies, soft enchanting piano, and clean guitar arrangement reaches the brilliance of what you would expect from Death Cab For Cutie. It is this final remark that lets you know they can still bring it to the table.
While I am disappointed in this release, it still stands as a good album. Death Cab For Cutie seem to have experienced what many bands do on their sophomore album. That is, not a bad album, just one that does not stand up to the level in which previous releases have set. If this was taken as a first release, it would stand tall as a very good album, but unfortunately, Death Cab For Cutie set the bar a bit too high, and then continued releasing at that level. That is, until now.
Highlights include: Bixby Canyon Bridge, Grapevine Fires and The Ice Is Getting Thinner.

MP3: “Grapevine Fires” – Death Cab For Cutie